Advantages and disadvantages of 360 degree feedback
Solutions / 360 Degree Feedback / Advantages and disadvantages of 360 degree feedback
The assessment of managers using 360-degree feedback is an extremely effective tool.
It not only promotes the professional and personal skills of the manager, but also strengthens the position of the company through competent and trained employees.
The comprehensive assessment from different perspectives allows weaknesses to be identified and improved in a targeted manner and strengths to be further developed.
In this way, 360-degree feedback not only contributes to the individual development of the manager, but also to the success and competitiveness of the entire company.
Find out below about the advantages and disadvantages of 360-degree feedback.
Advantages of 360 degree feedback
The advantages of 360 degree feedback clearly outweigh the disadvantages and show that implementation brings more benefits for all parties involved:
1st advantage: Fast implementation
Thanks to the use of tools and suitable software, 360-degree feedback can be implemented quickly.
This means that companies no longer have to rely on lengthy manual processes to collect and process feedback from various sources.
The implementation of appropriate technologies enables the smooth collection of feedback from different perspectives, be it from superiors, colleagues or subordinates.
In addition, the results can be automatically aggregated and analyzed, which significantly reduces the administrative effort and shortens the overall time required to carry out the feedback process.
This enables organizations to react more quickly to the feedback received and initiate targeted measures to improve employee development and organizational growth.
2nd advantage: Measurable results
By tailoring the questions to the specific needs of the company and implementing 360-degree feedback digitally, you not only gain comprehensive insights, but also measurable results.
The structured collection of data makes it possible to conduct quantitative and qualitative analyses to gain concrete insights into the performance, behavior and skills of employees.
These measurable results serve as a valuable basis for deriving measures for individual development and for optimizing team and organizational structures.
In addition, the results obtained can be used effectively to conduct targeted discussions with managers.
The data enables a well-founded discussion about employees’ strengths, development areas and career goals.
This not only promotes transparency and openness within the team, but also helps to create individual development plans that are tailored to the specific needs and goals of each employee.
3rd advantage: Comparison of own and external perspectives
The great advantage of 360-degree feedback lies in the holistic perspective that is made possible by comparing the manager’s self-assessment with the assessments of employees, colleagues and customers.
This comparison provides managers with a realistic picture of how their perceptions and assessments match or differ from the opinions and observations of others in their professional environment.
This comparison allows both strengths and areas for development to be clearly identified.
It enables managers to recognize their personal blindspots and possible discrepancies between how they perceive themselves and how others perceive them and to take targeted measures for personal and professional development based on this.
These insights not only promote self-reflection and an understanding of one’s own impact on others, but also support the process of continuous improvement and growth as a manager.
4th advantage: Promoting executives
The aim of 360-degree feedback is the targeted promotion and further development of managers’ skills.
By using this feedback mechanism, not only the strengths but also the weak points and development areas of the manager are uncovered.
The variety of perspectives gained through feedback from employees, colleagues and customers enables a comprehensive analysis of leadership skills and behavior.
By identifying weaknesses and development areas, targeted development measures and training programs can be designed to support the manager in their deficits and increase their performance.
This can be done through coaching, mentoring or training in specific skills or behaviors, for example.
360-degree feedback therefore serves as a valuable tool for individual development and for increasing the effectiveness of managers, which ultimately leads to a positive impact on the entire team and the organization.
5th advantage: Relief from management
At the same time, supporting managers relieves the burden on management, as managers are better able to implement their areas of responsibility and management has to intervene less.
This contributes to a more efficient way of working, as the 360-degree feedback provides managers with targeted support in strengthening their skills and improving their weak points.
By empowering managers to fulfill their role more effectively and tackle challenges independently, the burden on management is also reduced.
This allows management to focus on strategic tasks and drive the development of the company instead of constantly having to deal with operational matters.
Disadvantages of 360 degree feedback
The potential drawbacks of 360 degree feedback should be discussed prior to implementation to ensure that nothing stands in the way of your survey success:
1st disadvantage: Pillory a manager
360-degree feedback should not be used as a “channel” to pillory a manager.
Rather, it should be seen as a constructive tool aimed at supporting managers in their personal and professional development.
The diverse perspectives offered by feedback can identify strengths and uncover weaknesses, but always with the aim of facilitating constructive improvements.
Watch the video below to learn how to avoid pillorying a manager and instead create a supportive environment that encourages individual development and growth.
Please activate the subtitles to add helpful text in your language to the audio
2nd disadvantage: No usable results if the mood is bad
If there is a tense relationship between employees and managers in the company, it is all the more important that there is open communication about the “why?” of conducting such a feedback process before the 360-degree feedback.
By communicating the reasons and objectives transparently, possible misunderstandings or fears on the part of employees and managers can be addressed.
This open communication creates trust and shows that the feedback serves as a tool for improvement and further development rather than as a means of criticism or punishment.
Only on this basis can you achieve usable results and lay the foundation for further surveys, as employees are more willing to respond constructively and honestly when they are in a supportive and understanding environment.
3rd disadvantage: No action from results
Finally, it is important that concrete measures are taken after the 360-degree feedback.
Without follow-up measures, there is a risk that the implementation will be “burnt out” immediately after the first time and trust in the feedback process will be lost.
If there is not much scope for comprehensive measures due to a lack of resources, it is advisable to communicate this transparently from the outset and to focus on implementing measures with the greatest potential effect.
In this way, everyone involved is informed and at least a noticeable improvement can be achieved.
It is important that all feedback participants recognize that their feedback is taken seriously and leads to concrete action.
This not only strengthens trust in the feedback process, but also promotes a climate of continuous improvement and commitment.
Further measures can then follow successively as soon as the resources are available.
Further information
